| Author | I invite admins to prove their word. add a (?) button to WG errand lines. |
|---|
-1 to the idea of paying to see the battle were someone did it with 3 stars (as in post 1)
+1 to see the battle but then you cannot do the task anymore (suggested cost twice the reward).
The problem with WG is that the enemy and the field are exactly in the same configuration it was won on, so unless AI change, Micro balancing, Luck and Moral burst, you should be able to reproduce the battle step by step.
This is not the case with hunt record, since when you join you do not know how many stack you get.
Did anyone ever tried to use 4 level chaos in a 2 stack hunt instead of a 4 stack one? It change everything. |
for Lord MathProfessor:
So what if you can copy to win the WG task? Are you implying that learning how to fight by watching others is undesirable for a regular guild? I think, as long as the use is limited in some way so that players cannot watch all 3 quests either before or after to secure a win, this shouldn't be discouraged. This is just my opinion, but i do think i would prefer atleast to know if a certain battle really is doable.
Besides, AI change is too big of a factor to be listed along with the likes of triggers and microbalancing..
For example, if you watch a WG battle i did recently you will realize i would have had absolutely no chance if the AI were simply defending with all its army.
https://www.lordswm.com/war.php?warid=776283144 |
unless AI change, Micro balancing, Luck and Moral burst, you should be able to reproduce the battle step by step
You forgot the min-max damage from all troops. That alone guarantees you will NOT reproduce the battle step by step.
And all factions (except necro) having at least 1 morale...
That said, revealing the Battle at the cost of never ever being able to play it is a good suggestion. |
You forgot the min-max damage from all troops. That alone guarantees you will NOT reproduce the battle step by step.
And all factions (except necro) having at least 1 morale...
That said, revealing the Battle at the cost of never ever being able to play it is a good suggestion.
Min-max damage is not always present or it might not have any effect on specific battle.
I didn't propose that he can never again do it, just not for that day.
If user get the same task (with the same exact battle) on another day and he remember every single step... can I have his memory enhancement pills?
BTW, not all faction have at least 1 moral:
- Demoralizing presence (Shadow Dragon in enemy army)
- Talent: Fallen knight (Knight faction) |
| And yes, I missed min-max in my list |
+1 to the Idea.
The cost could be the inability to do that mission once the tactic / battle has been viewed
Agree with AKA. :) |
| nice idea,except the price,1 diamond too much |
+1 to the idea
obviously all this arguing about cost is pointless as should this ever be implemented. do you really think they will listen to the costs we think makes sense :D
but i also believe if your paying for something then you have every right to copy the strategy, plus it could be a great teaching experience for those WG noobs out there (like me)
:D |
