| Author | traders guild |
|---|
kiwi is right...
You could change it to only buying things from the actual places on the map. that would keep out the abuse of the market. |
| I also agree that Kiwi is right, but that shouldn't be the deciding factor as to whether the Trader's Guild should be added. By your reason, we should not have PVP because people will go afk. People are going to find loopholes & ways to cheat regardless. But on the other hand, for those players who really enjoy the market aspect & are already making a fortune on the market, this would be a way for them to measure their skill. Plus it would be fun, just like earning a LG level, TG level or MG level & don't tell me that it doesn't give that big an advantage over your opponent. |
i dont see any problem if people buy items and then selling it for higher price
this is not cheating but trading...
and main profit of players it would still be enrolment
this suggestion intention is to make trading a little more funny anh hopefully drag more players to market
PS: for those who you think you can make fortune on market...
buying resourses in mining facilities and than selling on on market makes you 0.5 - 1% profit
for ore that is 1 - 2 gold on each ore
for 10 000 gold you have to sell about 6 500 ore
as you can see you wont get rich joust with buyin and selling on market |
| That is where you are wrong. You can, but it takes time & patiences. |
Pupek
i did not say that trading was cheating, trading is ok (within limits), but thats a different discussion.
what i said is that it is so easy to cheat yourself to lvl 10 in this guild.
I promise you there will be people lvl 10 within 1 day.
So this guild is not feasable and wont be implemted. thats all i said.
it's a nice idea, but it needs much more details and rules to be implemented |
OK. what we are discussing here is the idea, not the details. i agree with kiwi that it will be very easy to cheat, given those circumstances. i discarded the guild points detail by the only reason they could be easily tuned at the end. and don't forget the commission paid to the Empire for every successful sell. this will surely prevent most of the fake buyers/sellers from climbing the TG (traders' guild) ladder.
just an example: the traders' guild level 1 could be achieved by making let's say... 100 000 gold clear profit. even the best traders can't make more than 20k profit for a weekend. levels 1,2,3 etc. are pretty much discussable, tunable, whatever you like.
i'd read Kyrian's post #22 once or twice before continuing the discussion. |
I definately think that this idea has potiential, and that a Trader's Guild would be a much welcomed addition to the game, and I reckon alot of other players would agree with me.
It undoubtably needs a bit of fine tuning to stop cheats taking advantage of it, like perhaps there is a limit on how much you can buy from other players every day, and I was thinking that the points would be given on how much money you made, not the profit on the item (so even if you made a loss on a lot, you would still get points on it). However, I think that if people commented on this idea, then I'm certain that a system could be worked out.
And Georgia, to what you said before about the admins never looking at the IaS forum, but if there is good idea being discussed then they've got to take note, as if they don't take in ideas and suggestions, then whats the point of even having an Ideas and Suggestions forum? |
@Kyrian enroling is still muh more easy way to make get money
@kiwi i doubt anyone have so much money...
cheating would be buying and selling from each other?
u sell something to your friend and your friend sell it back to you...
so how to prevent this
its very simple...
u get one trading point for selling goods for 1000 gold
but if u sell somthing worth 2000 gold u still get one point...
level 1 100
level 2 200
level 3 400
...
level 10 51200
so if there would be 10 levels you would have to sell 99 900 000 gold worth goods
and if commision drops from 1% to 0,5% on level 10... average commision would be like 0,6% you would spent 5 994 000 just for commision
and market is hero to make money not to loose it... |
Bad idea. Huge "-"
It will cause a lot of competitors. By the way - trading sux on this server with such quantity of online players. 1300 max.
And as for me I prefer to buy something on the map. |
| For autor http://www.heroeswm.ru/killhydra.php?r=1 |
